Employment prospects in the UK continue to improve, but growth is slow and confidence has not yet returned to pre-September 11th 2001 levels, according to Manpower's Quarterly Survey of Employment Prospects. The service and financial sectors are particularly depressed, providing further evidence of a lack of business confidence.
"Employment prospects are up 3 points on last quarter and are the strongest this year, but are still down 2 points year-on-year and at their lowest level for the fourth quarter since 1995," said Iain Herbertson, Manpower's UK managing director. "All sectors and regions we survey are planning to increase staffing levels, but not at the pace we were expecting, given the underlying strength of the UK economy and flexibility of our labour market, both of which support work creation."
The Manpower survey asks over 2,000 UK companies, split into 11 regions and 21 industry sectors, if they expect an increase, decrease or no change in their staffing levels for the quarter ahead. For the fourth quarter, 28% said they would be increasing staffing levels; 10% expect to decrease staffing levels; leaving a 'net balance' of 18% planning to take on new staff.
High street retailers are anticipating a 34% increase in jobs for Q4, but a closer look shows that prospects in the sector are in decline. This time last year, the sector was top of the league table, when 65% of employers predicted staff increases in the fourth quarter. That number is down 32 points (the steepest fall of all the sectors) and is at its lowest Q4 level for the last 10 years. "Christmas is the busiest time of the year in the high street and quarter 4 is traditionally a time when lots of new jobs are created here. Prospects are up for the fourth quarter this year, but not at the level we would expect for this time of year, indicating that retailers are bracing themselves for a fall in consumer spending." comments Herbertson.
Employment trends in Hotels & Restaurants add weight to a view that consumer confidence - or at least business confidence in consumer spending - may be waning. The sector had shown a strong recovery from the foot and mouth crisis and the impact on tourism of September 11th, and was the most buoyant sector for jobs in the third quarter. But it has suffered the greatest quarter-on-quarter decrease - falling by 20 points from a net balance of 41% to 21% - and second largest year-on-year decrease of any sector.
The Health sector is the UK's strongest for jobs, with 38% of employers planning to increase staffing levels in the period October-December. Job prospects are up 13 points year-on-year and have reached a 10-year high for Q4. Prospects in Manufacturing are also improving, up 3 points on Q3. But services, although also up 3 points since the last quarter, are down 9 points year-on-year.
Employment prospects in other sectors are mixed. The Electronics sector, which had been in decline until last quarter, continues to recover, with 17% of companies expecting to take on more staff in quarter 4. Education, which predicted cut backs in the third quarter, is expecting to take on staff in the fourth (net balance of 9%). Transport expects the largest quarter-on-quarter increase, up 19 points to a net balance of 27% of companies planning to hire. Much of this is likely to be down to a recruitment drive for drivers, to fill the estimated 40,000 vacancies in the UK driving industry.
Media & Sport and Financial have the worst job prospects, well below the national average of 18%, with only 4% and 5% of companies respectively in these sectors expecting to take on staff. Prospects in Media & Sport had rallied in the last quarter, most likely buoyed by activity around the World Cup and Commonwealth Games. Employment prospects in the Financial sector remain poor, with continued uncertainty in the markets.
Around the country, all regions plan to take on more staff in the fourth quarter. However, although 8 of the 11 regions are displaying greater optimism than last quarter, only 4 of the 11 are more optimistic now than they were a year ago.
The North-West is at a 10-year high with 22% of companies planning to take on more staff. The region shows the greatest year-on-year increase in the UK. The North East is up by 7 points quarter-on-quarter, but down 16 points year-on-year. London, which has been hit hardest of all the regions by the events of 2001-2, is showing signs of recovery, up quarter-on-quarter and year-on-year, with 15% of companies planning to hire. Manpower has seen strong growth in public sector prospects in the policing, education, immigration and probationary service areas, which reflects government spending.
Other strong regions include the West Midlands, with 27% of companies planning to take on staff making it the strongest region; Wales, which reports a balance of 26% of companies planning to hire; the South East and East, both with a net balance of 18%. However, Scotland (10% net job gains), the South West and Yorkshire & Humberside (both 14%) all remain cautious.
"A huge amount of uncertainty remains in the labour market. Our customers are telling us that they are busy, but they still feel nervous about adding to overhead, which makes flexible staffing solutions a useful option." says Herbertson.
|Manpower's Quarterly Survey of Employment Prospects, now in its thirty-fifth
year of publication, is one of the most respected indices of employment
trends in the country. It is widely used in Government and industry,
including The Bank of England's Monetary Policy Committee as evidence of
labour market activity.
The survey covers a UK-spread of company board directors, general managers and company secretaries. This latest research was conducted in August 2002, amongst 3000 companies in 22 industry sectors.
Copies of the survey are available from the Manpower Press Office: telephone 020 8870 2214; or e-mail [email protected]