Skip to main content

Too much cream sinks fat cat

Jul 01 2004 by Brian Amble
Print This Article

Sainsbury’s chairman Sir Peter Davis has been forced out of his job following a row with institutional shareholders over his controversial £2.4m bonus.

In May Sainsbury’s provoked widespread astonishment by awarding Davis the bonus - representing 86 per cent of his maximum payout under his ‘performance-related’ incentive scheme - despite his presiding over an 8.5 per cent drop in the company’s annual profits.

Then in May, the company reported a 2.9 per cent fall in profits and falling sales.

Davis became Sainsbury's chairman three months ago after spending four years as group chief executive. The appointment - which was contrary to corporate governance guidelines – was unpopular with many investors from the start.

It was pressure from these same institutional investors that forced Davis to resign at an emergency board meeting on Wednesday.

Investors had warned the company that it faced shareholder revolt against directors' pay unless he was removed.

The move marks a new milestone in investor muscle as the major institutions revolt against so-called ‘rewards for failure’ enjoyed by the executives of poorly-performing companies.

It has been widely reported that over the past few weeks, Lord Levene, a Sainsbury’s non-executive director, has been trying to broker a deal with disgruntled investors whereby Davis would give back ten per cent of the disputed bonus.

But investors rejected the offer, which would still have seen Davis given a further 1.5 million in shares in the spring of 2005.

They gave the Sainsbury's 48 hours to axe the bonus scheme or face a hugely embarrassing vote against the remuneration report at the annual general meeting next month.

It is unclear how much of his bonus pot Davis will keep as a result of his resignation. But under the terms of his deal, he was entitled to keep half of the £1.5 million due to him is 2005 even if he got sacked.

Latest book reviews

MORE BOOK REVIEWS

Relationship Currency

Relationship Currency

Ravi Rajani

In an era where AI can draft emails and manage our schedules, 'Relationship Currency' is a timely reminder of the importance of investing in genuine human connection.

Super Adaptability: How to Transcend in an Age of Overwhelm

Super Adaptability: How to Transcend in an Age of Overwhelm

Max McKeown

Max Mckeown's heavyweight new book draws from neuroscience, psychology and cultural evolution to develop a practical framework for human adaptability.

The Confidence Myth

The Confidence Myth

Ginka Toegel

How can women leaders break free from gendered perceptions? Professor Ginka Toegel’s new book challenges the narrative that female leaders lack confidence or that women need to "fix" themselves, arguing for a fundamental shift in how organisations recognise and reward competence.